IF THE STATE of the regular economy was not cause
enough for concern, the findings of the just released Symantec Report on the Underground Economy are even
more sobering, detailing an online underground econ
omy that has matured into an efficient, global market
place in which stolen goods and fraud-related services
are regularly bought and sold.
In fact, by monitoring criminals offering stolen credit
cards, bank account information and other stolen financial
data, Symantec researchers believe hundreds of millions
of dollars of potential theft tools are available at any time.
Credit card information is the most advertised cate
gory of goods and services on the underground economy,
accounting for 31 per cent of the total. While stolen
credit card numbers sell for as little as US10c to $US25
per card, the average advertised stolen credit card limit
is more than $US4000 ($6135).
Between the reporting period of 1 July 2007 and
30 June 2008, Symantec calculated that the potential
worth of all credit cards advertised was a staggering
$US5.3 billion.
The popularity of credit card information is arguably
attributable to the many ways this information can be
obtained and used for fraud; credit cards
are easy to use for online shopping and
it is often difficult for merchants or credit
card providers to identify and address
fraudulent transactions before they are
completed. Also, credit card information
is often sold to fraudsters in bulk, with
discounts or free numbers provided with
larger purchases.
“Today’s cyber criminals are thriv
ing off of information they are gather
ing without permission from businesses
and consumers,” said Symantec Secu
rity Technology and Response vice
president Stephen Trilling.
“As these individuals and groups
continue to devise new tools and tech
niques to defraud legitimate users
around the globe, protection and mit
igation against such attacks must
become an international priority.”
The second most common category
of goods and services advertised is
financial accounts, at 20 per cent of
the total. While stolen bank account
information sells for between $US10
and $US1000, the average advertised
stolen bank account balance is nearly
$40,000. Calculating the average
advertised balance of a bank account,
together with the average price for
stolen bank account numbers, the
worth of the bank accounts advertised
during the reporting period was
$US1.7 billion.
According to Trilling, financial
account information is popular among
cyber criminals because of its poten
tial for high payouts and the speed at
which payouts can be made. In one
case, financial accounts were cashed
out online to untraceable locations in
less than 15 minutes.
Alarmingly, the underground
economy is geographically diverse
and generates revenue for cyber crim
inals who range from loose collec
tions of individuals to organised and
sophisticated groups.
North America hosts the largest
number of such servers, with 45 per
cent of the total, Europe/Middle
East/Africa 38 per cent, followed by
Asia/Pacific with 12 per cent and
Latin America five per cent.
The geographical locations of
underground economy servers are
constantly changing to evade detec
tion, with 98 per cent of them having
life spans of less than six months.
In the one year covered by the
report, more than 69,000 distinct
advertisers and 44 million online mes
sages were monitored selling illicit
credit card and financial data, but the
10 most active advertisers appeared
to account for 11 per cent of the total
messages posted.