THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY and
regulators should use the current global
financial crisis to drive a constructive
evolution of regulatory guidance,
according to Ernst & Young’s Global
Insurance Centre.
Although the insurance industry
faces fewer urgent liquidity challenges
compared with banks, the valuation of
assets has been severely affected by the
crisis, and capital reserves in many
insurance companies have been signif
icantly depleted.
“This is a clear sign that the inter
connected web of the global financial
markets has far greater implications
than the industry could have predicted,”
said Ernst & Young Solvency II Task
force leader Philipp Keller.
“The significant impact of the finan
cial crisis highlights the need for
enhanced risk management. It is our
view that a principles-based, economic
and risk-sensitive approach such as
Solvency II, grounded in solid gover
nance and supervisory principles, is the
right response at this time. This will
produce timely, consistent and trans
parent messages to the public.
“Principles-based regulation places
responsibility for risk management with
the management and board of the regu
lated companies,” Keller said. “It drives
risk management standards appropriate
to the complexity of the business. This
will foster understanding and account
ability for the risks taken, but will also
produce a major challenge for manage
ment teams and boards.”
However, according to Keller, it is
important to recognise that a regulatory
framework such as Solvency II in its
currently anticipated form, while a sig
nificant improvement on current pru
dential supervision, will never be able
to provide all the answers and can be
only one element of sound risk and cap
ital management.
Given this, he said, industry and reg
ulators should make use of events such as
the current financial crisis to drive a con
structive evolution of regulatory guid
ance. This, he maintained, should
complement the Solvency II regime with
short-term liquidity testing and cash flow
analysis to allow a more holistic
approach to anticipating the impact of
adverse events, and place more empha
sis on the articulation and testing of com
pany-specific threat scenarios, in addition
to the standard quantitative requirements.
Keller also noted, however, that
Insurers often focus their attention on
traditional areas of financial risk. While
this is not surprising or unusual, he
warned that Solvency II will require the
global insurance industry to pay closer
attention to an often “forgotten” area –
operational risk.