AUSTRALIA’S FIRST ALTERNATIVE dispute res
olution (ADR) centre specialising in sci
ence, technology and intellectual
property has opened in Sydney. The
Technology Dispute Centre (TDC) com
prises Fellow and Senior Fellow media
tors and arbitrators with training and
aptitude in the three areas.
According to Philip Argy of ArgyS
tar.com, a Senior Fellow and founder of
the centre, it is one of the few centres of
its kind anywhere in the world.
“It will offer a wide range of services
to assist businesses to avoid and resolve
commercial disputes, with centre-of-excel
lence focus on those disputes which involve
some kind of scientific or technological
subject matter,” he said.
Argy explained that it is often difficult
to achieve a satisfactory resolution to
technology-related disputes through tra
ditional litigation or dispute resolution
channels, because of the complex nature
of the subject matter.
“Historically lawyers are trained in
the humanities and not in science and
technology, and some are even technol
ogy-averse,” he said. “The consequence
is that they cannot generate options for
the parties to consider that take account
of the technical possibilities.”
Similar problems often arise when mat
ters hit the courts, with cases becoming a
“battle of experts”.
“If it’s a particularly arcane techni
cal area you might as well throw a dice,”
Argy maintained. “A judge often cannot
choose between two experts, so the like
lihood that the truth will come out is
quite low. Certainly the parties are not going to help a judge understand the issues
– they’re just trying to get a decision in
their favour.”
A key motivation for the centre’s
establishment was a survey con
ducted in 2006 which found that in
excess of 40 per cent of information
and communications technology
(ICT) contracts resulted in some form
of dispute.
The same survey identified ADR
as the preferred method of resolving
disputes.
“Litigation is costly, complex and
disruptive to business,” Argy noted.
“The TDC will, therefore, specialise
in avoiding and resolving commer
cial disputes in the high-technology
sector, as well as providing conven
tional commercial dispute resolution
services.
Its establishment recognises a
growing international trend towards
mediation and arbitration as the pre
ferred means for resolving disputes.”
Sir Laurence Street, AC KCMG
QC and former Chief Justice of NSW,
noted the centre’s importance:
“Never before has it been more crit
ical for business to take advantage of
the considerable commercial advan
tages which can flow from the timely
and effective negotiation and settle
ment of complex technology-related
disputes.”